[ Suggestion ] Deprecate Minesweeper for Flower Field

Landmines are indiscriminate and inhumane. Microsoft renamed Minesweeper to “Flower Field” in some versions of Windows for Italy[1], Germany[1], South Korea, Japan and Taiwan.

To remove offense to minefield victims, Sergio Chiodo ran an international campaign to rename it in 1999. Italy used to be one of the world’s largest manufacturers of landmines.

Gino Strada[2], an Italian war surgeon, detailed the removal of shrapnal embossed with the words “Made in Italy”. His diary Green Parrots ( ISBN 8881584204 ) caused such an uproar back home in Italy that his diary was instrumental in getting Italy to ban landline production.

“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.” — Margaret Mead

https://web.archive.org/web/20020409051321fw_/http://rcm.usr.dsi.unimi.it/rcmweb/fnm/

2 Likes

Feels a lot like the green bottles re-implementation we did, also started by you @habere-et-dispertire :partying_face:.

As similar reasoning applies, I would be in favour of a similar PR that introduces a new exercise Flower Field and deprecates the old one (Minesweeper), in order to maintain integrity of mentoring sessions, commentary, links to solutions, and so forth, which all may refer to mines instead of flowers.

If there are two more maintainers who agree with this (and there are no big objections), feel free to PR it and tag those maintainers (including myself) for review for swift approval.

Thanks for bringing this up!

3 Likes

I’m with DJ here: I hard agree on a new name, but think we should follow the green bottles vs beer song pattern. :smile:

1 Like

It is easy to agree on a name that is already used in Italy, I would think, as the Windows game is well known, internationally, even if it is known as a different name.

We can also give a link to bring awareness of the offending thing, lest it be forgotten, the Surgeon’s experience and want to make such things being laid a crime.

1 Like

I also very much support making the world a less militarised one. And I don’t care for the new name. @habere-et-dispertire Thanks for your suggestions!

Does this mean you don’t care what name is used? Or that you dislike the proposed name?

2 Likes

I don’t care which name is used. I didn’t know this could be misunderstood…English is complicated for non-natives.

4 Likes

English is weird. To “not care for” is a “polite” way of saying you dislike it.

2 Likes

There are more than 3 maintainers in agreement @habere-et-dispertire . Feel free to open the PR and link it here so we can sign off.

2 Likes

Flower field exercise icon
flower-field.cleaned

5 Likes

Problem-specifications PR

Website-icons PR

2 Likes

exercism/problem-specifications#2575 reopened.

1 Like

It was merged! <3

3 Likes

Alright, I see a lot of tracks that implemented (and haven’t yet deprecated) Minesweeper.

37/49 Tracks Still Implementing Minesweeper
  1. ABAP
    AWK
    Bash
  2. C
  3. C#
  4. C++
  5. Cairo
  6. Clojure
    CoffeeScript
  7. Crystal
    Dart
  8. Delphi Pascal
  9. Elixir
    Elm
    Emacs Lisp
  10. Erlang
  11. F#
  12. Gleam
  13. Go
  14. Haskell
  15. Java
  16. JavaScript
    jq
    Julia
  17. Kotlin
  18. MIPS Assembly
  19. OCaml
  20. Perl
  21. Pharo
  22. PHP
  23. PowerShell
  24. Prolog
    Python
    Racket
  25. ReasonML
  26. Roc
  27. Ruby
  28. Rust
  29. Scala
  30. Swift
  31. Tcl
  32. TypeScript
  33. Uiua
  34. Unison
  35. V
    Vim script
    Visual Basic
  36. WebAssembly
  37. YAMLScript

Gonna do Python, just haven’t quite yet got around to it. Should be done in the next day or two. :grimacing:

1 Like

PR for bash

3 Likes

Just merged changes for Julia.

3 Likes

PR for Python.

3 Likes

PR for awk

3 Likes

PR for jq

2 Likes